research-document
Hypothesis Review Input v2
Hypothesis Review Input v2
| Hypothesis | Evidence From Comparator v2 | Possible Direction | Notes | Reviewer Decision Needed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| H003 Multi-model convergence | Semantic improvement cases=38; semantic disagreements=5. | unclear | Semantic normalization increases apparent overlap in some fields, but this remains a measurement aid rather than proof of convergence. | Yes |
| H012 Vocabulary bias | Literal disagreements=29; semantic improvements=38. | possible_strengthen | If semantic overlap rises where literal disagreement remains, wording drift may be inflating apparent disagreement. | Yes |
| H013 Recognition bias | Comparator v2 does not isolate recognition effects; unresolved items=200. | unclear | Semantic normalization does not remove recognition as a threat and should not be read as evidence against bias. | Yes |
| H015 Measurement instrument reliability | Valid=8; malformed=1; unresolved normalized items=200. | unclear | Semantic grouping may clarify wording drift, but unresolved items and malformed data still limit interpretation. | Yes |
Do not update confidence from this file. Reviewer judgment is still required.