ECR-000001 Comparator v3 Report

Purpose

Report literal agreement, flat semantic agreement, and role-first dimensional agreement without hiding surface disagreement.

Why v3 Exists

• v2 could over-merge phrases that shared an object noun but differed in procedural role.
• v3 separates role, object, purpose, stage, and control flow.
• role is primary, so object overlap alone cannot create equivalence.

v1 / v2 / v3 Behavior

• v1 literal full/partial/disagreement/unclear: 0/20/29/5
• v2 flat semantic full/partial/disagreement/unclear: 37/2/5/10
• v3 dimensional full/partial/disagreement/unclear: 25/18/6/5

False-Positive Reduction

• Fields reduced from flat-semantic full agreement to a weaker dimensional result: 15.
• v3 false-positive candidates: 0.
• v3 validation recommendation: safe_for_limited_calibration_use.

Unresolved Items

• Unresolved dimensional matches recorded: 708.

Caution

• v3 is still provisional.
• Literal disagreement remains visible and is not overridden by dimensional matching.
• Dimensional agreement is a measurement aid, not proof of equivalence.