Framework Engineering Research

An open index of evidence, theory, and practice

research-document

ECR-000001 Packet Verification Report

Research Area
General Research
Status
draft
Version
0.1
Priority
medium
Updated
2026-07-22
Source
research/evidence-runs/ECR-000001-multi-layer-procedural-representation/packet-verification-report.md

ECR-000001 Packet Verification Report

Summary

Overall status: PASS WITH WARNINGS

Packet Results

Packet Status Blocking Issues Warnings
ECR-000001-P001-scientific-method PASS WITH WARNINGS None Blinded content remains highly recognizable as a canonical inquiry cycle.
ECR-000001-P002-scrum-workflow PASS WITH WARNINGS None Terms such as "short-cycle goal" and "usable increment" still point toward the source artifact.
ECR-000001-P003-bloom-taxonomy PASS WITH WARNINGS None The hierarchical classification phrasing remains recognizable as a taxonomy-style artifact.

Detailed Checks

ECR-000001-P001

Required Content

Requirement Status Notes
packet_id present PASS packet_id is present.
blinded_artifact_id present PASS blinded_artifact_id is present.
blinded content section present PASS blinded_procedural_content is present.
source artifact name not exposed in prompt body PASS The source name does not appear in the packet body.
standard observation-only instructions present PASS All required instruction clauses are present.
full response schema embedded directly PASS Complete JSON schema is embedded in the packet.
structural_layer fields complete PASS All required structural fields are present.
primitive_layer fields complete PASS All required primitive fields are present.
constraint_layer fields complete PASS All required constraint fields are present.
representation_layer fields complete PASS All required representation fields are present.
product_relevance_layer fields complete PASS All required product relevance observation fields are present.
confidence fields complete PASS All required confidence fields are present.

Forbidden Content

Forbidden Item Status Notes
hypothesis_implications PASS Not present.
hypothesis_id PASS Not present.
effect PASS Not present.
strengthens PASS Not present.
weakens PASS Not present.
unchanged PASS Not present.
asks model to update hypotheses PASS Explicitly prohibited.
asks model to validate Framework Engineering PASS Explicitly prohibited.
asks model to validate Clarity PASS Not present.
asks model to validate EDF PASS Not present.
local file references PASS No external schema or primitive-definition file references appear.
TODO PASS Not present.
unresolved placeholders PASS No {{...}} placeholders present.

ECR-000001-P002

Required Content

Requirement Status Notes
packet_id present PASS packet_id is present.
blinded_artifact_id present PASS blinded_artifact_id is present.
blinded content section present PASS blinded_procedural_content is present.
source artifact name not exposed in prompt body PASS The source name does not appear in the packet body.
standard observation-only instructions present PASS All required instruction clauses are present.
full response schema embedded directly PASS Complete JSON schema is embedded in the packet.
structural_layer fields complete PASS All required structural fields are present.
primitive_layer fields complete PASS All required primitive fields are present.
constraint_layer fields complete PASS All required constraint fields are present.
representation_layer fields complete PASS All required representation fields are present.
product_relevance_layer fields complete PASS All required product relevance observation fields are present.
confidence fields complete PASS All required confidence fields are present.

Forbidden Content

Forbidden Item Status Notes
hypothesis_implications PASS Not present.
hypothesis_id PASS Not present.
effect PASS Not present.
strengthens PASS Not present.
weakens PASS Not present.
unchanged PASS Not present.
asks model to update hypotheses PASS Explicitly prohibited.
asks model to validate Framework Engineering PASS Explicitly prohibited.
asks model to validate Clarity PASS Not present.
asks model to validate EDF PASS Not present.
local file references PASS No external schema or primitive-definition file references appear.
TODO PASS Not present.
unresolved placeholders PASS No {{...}} placeholders present.

ECR-000001-P003

Required Content

Requirement Status Notes
packet_id present PASS packet_id is present.
blinded_artifact_id present PASS blinded_artifact_id is present.
blinded content section present PASS blinded_procedural_content is present.
source artifact name not exposed in prompt body PASS The source name does not appear in the packet body.
standard observation-only instructions present PASS All required instruction clauses are present.
full response schema embedded directly PASS Complete JSON schema is embedded in the packet.
structural_layer fields complete PASS All required structural fields are present.
primitive_layer fields complete PASS All required primitive fields are present.
constraint_layer fields complete PASS All required constraint fields are present.
representation_layer fields complete PASS All required representation fields are present.
product_relevance_layer fields complete PASS All required product relevance observation fields are present.
confidence fields complete PASS All required confidence fields are present.

Forbidden Content

Forbidden Item Status Notes
hypothesis_implications PASS Not present.
hypothesis_id PASS Not present.
effect PASS Not present.
strengthens PASS Not present.
weakens PASS Not present.
unchanged PASS Not present.
asks model to update hypotheses PASS Explicitly prohibited.
asks model to validate Framework Engineering PASS Explicitly prohibited.
asks model to validate Clarity PASS Not present.
asks model to validate EDF PASS Not present.
local file references PASS No external schema or primitive-definition file references appear.
TODO PASS Not present.
unresolved placeholders PASS No {{...}} placeholders present.

Blocking Issues

None identified.

Warnings

  • Packet blinding is acceptable for execution, but all three packets remain fairly recognizable from their procedural wording.
  • ECR-000001-P001-scientific-method is especially recognizable because its inquiry loop uses canonical science-process phrasing.
  • ECR-000001-P002-scrum-workflow includes wording such as "usable increment" that strongly cues the source artifact.
  • ECR-000001-P003-bloom-taxonomy is not named directly, but its hierarchical challenge-level phrasing remains recognizable as a classification artifact.
  • For ECR-000001-P001, replace the current inquiry-cycle wording with a less canonical paraphrase while preserving the same procedural structure.
  • For ECR-000001-P002, consider replacing usable increment and short-cycle goal with more neutral execution language.
  • For ECR-000001-P003, consider paraphrasing the hierarchy description more indirectly to reduce recognition without changing the control-artifact role.
  • Keep the embedded observation-only schema and instruction block unchanged unless a future QA pass finds a concrete execution problem.

Ready with warnings.