hypothesis
H003 — Multi-Model Convergence
H003 — Multi-Model Convergence
Status Before Review
Ready for limited review.
Why This Hypothesis Is In Scope
The dashboard marks H003 as ready for limited review.
Evidence Available
- Comparator v1/v2/v3
- Dashboard says ready for limited review
Supporting Observations
- v3 dimensional agreement improved over literal comparison
- dashboard says ready yes limited
Challenging Observations
- malformed GPT P001 response
- recognition remains high
- unresolved dimensional matches remain high
Threats To Validity
- one malformed response reduces confidence in cross-model completeness
- recognition may inflate apparent convergence
Instrument Issues
- malformed GPT P001
- unresolved dimensional matches
Reviewer Assessment
Choose one:
- insufficient_evidence
- tentatively_supported
- tentatively_challenged
- mixed_evidence
- blocked_by_instrument_issue
- defer_until_next_ecr
Rationale
Next Evidence Needed
- repaired or documented GPT P001 status
- unresolved-item sampling
Confidence Update Recommendation
Do not update confidence here.
Options:
- no_update
- prepare_increase_for_review_board
- prepare_decrease_for_review_board
- prepare_split_hypothesis
- prepare_suspend_hypothesis
- prepare_retire_hypothesis