Framework Engineering Research

An open index of evidence, theory, and practice

research-document

EDR Explainability Input

Research Area
General Research
Status
draft
Version
0.1
Priority
medium
Updated
2026-07-22
Source
research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/experiments/EXP-001-topology-perturbation/comparison/generated-v3.2-explainability/edr-explainability-input.md

EDR Explainability Input

Highest-Priority Differences

  • Baseline: gpt vs claude: high significance; 40 differences.
  • Baseline: gpt vs gemini: high significance; 30 differences.
  • Baseline: claude vs gemini: high significance; 53 differences.
  • Renumbered: gpt vs claude: high significance; 60 differences.
  • Renumbered: gpt vs gemini: high significance; 38 differences.
  • Renumbered: claude vs gemini: high significance; 45 differences.
  • Edge-Order Shuffled: gpt vs claude: high significance; 38 differences.
  • Edge-Order Shuffled: claude vs gemini: high significance; 51 differences.
  • Identity-Expanded: gpt vs claude: high significance; 51 differences.
  • Identity-Expanded: gpt vs gemini: high significance; 45 differences.
  • Identity-Expanded: claude vs gemini: high significance; 54 differences.
  • gpt: P001A vs P001B: high significance; 41 differences.
  • gpt: P001A vs P001D: high significance; 40 differences.
  • gpt: P001B vs P001C: high significance; 41 differences.
  • gpt: P001B vs P001D: high significance; 58 differences.
  • gpt: P001C vs P001D: high significance; 40 differences.
  • claude: P001A vs P001B: high significance; 58 differences.
  • claude: P001A vs P001C: high significance; 51 differences.
  • claude: P001A vs P001D: high significance; 62 differences.
  • claude: P001B vs P001C: high significance; 55 differences.
  • claude: P001B vs P001D: high significance; 66 differences.
  • claude: P001C vs P001D: high significance; 57 differences.
  • gemini: P001A vs P001B: high significance; 33 differences.
  • gemini: P001A vs P001C: high significance; 21 differences.
  • gemini: P001A vs P001D: high significance; 21 differences.
  • gemini: P001C vs P001D: high significance; 29 differences.

Low-Significance Differences

Recognition / Structure Relationship

  • Baseline: gpt vs claude: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • Baseline: gpt vs gemini: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • Baseline: claude vs gemini: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • Renumbered: gpt vs claude: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • Renumbered: claude vs gemini: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • Edge-Order Shuffled: gpt vs claude: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • Edge-Order Shuffled: gpt vs gemini: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • Edge-Order Shuffled: claude vs gemini: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • claude: P001A vs P001B: Both responses express only family resemblance rather than confident recognition.
  • claude: P001A vs P001C: Both responses express only family resemblance rather than confident recognition.
  • claude: P001A vs P001D: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • claude: P001B vs P001C: Both responses express only family resemblance rather than confident recognition.
  • claude: P001B vs P001D: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • claude: P001C vs P001D: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • gemini: P001A vs P001B: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • gemini: P001A vs P001D: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • gemini: P001B vs P001C: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.
  • gemini: P001C vs P001D: Recognition changed while the backbone remained stable.