Framework Engineering Research

An open index of evidence, theory, and practice

research-document

ECR-000003 Hypothesis Review Board Implementation Report

Research Area
General Research
Status
draft
Version
0.1
Priority
medium
Updated
2026-07-22
Source
research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/HRB-IMPLEMENTATION-REPORT.md

ECR-000003 Hypothesis Review Board Implementation Report

Deliverables

Deliverable Path Status Human Review Required
Readiness report research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/HRB-READINESS.md created yes
Board packet research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/HYPOTHESIS-REVIEW-BOARD-PACKET.md created yes
H002 review research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/hypotheses/H002-review.md created yes
H003 review research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/hypotheses/H003-review.md created yes
H013 review research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/hypotheses/H013-review.md created yes
H015 review research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/hypotheses/H015-review.md created yes
H016 review research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/hypotheses/H016-review.md created yes
H017 review research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/hypotheses/H017-review.md created yes
H018 review research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/hypotheses/H018-review.md created yes
Board summary research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/HYPOTHESIS-REVIEW-BOARD-SUMMARY.md created yes
Split candidates research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/HYPOTHESIS-SPLIT-CANDIDATES.md created yes
Kill-condition review research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/HYPOTHESIS-KILL-CONDITION-REVIEW.md created yes
Board decision record research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/HYPOTHESIS-REVIEW-BOARD-DECISION.md created yes
Matrix proposal research/operating-system/hypothesis-matrix-inputs/ECR-000003-HRB-proposal.md created yes
Next-research input research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/HRB-NEXT-RESEARCH-INPUT.md created yes
Verification report research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/HRB-VERIFICATION.md created yes

Readiness

  • Overall readiness: READY_WITH_WARNINGS
  • Blocking issues: none found
  • Warnings: placeholder summary EDR; limited claims-review input; explainability remains auxiliary

Reviews Created

  • Seven per-hypothesis review records with supporting and challenging evidence
  • Board-level summary and split review
  • Kill-condition review and next-research prioritization

Gaps

  • No accepted human baseline exists
  • H016 remains inadequately tested in accepted evidence
  • Constraint-layer disagreement remains under-calibrated

Split Candidates

  • strongest candidate: H013
  • possible future candidate: H003
  • premature candidates: H016, H017

Kill-Condition Concerns

  • Several kill conditions are too broad because they do not distinguish backbone-level weakening from detail-layer disagreement.

Exact Next Human Actions

  1. Open research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/HYPOTHESIS-REVIEW-BOARD-PACKET.md.
  2. Review all files in research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/hypotheses/.
  3. Review HYPOTHESIS-REVIEW-BOARD-SUMMARY.md, HYPOTHESIS-SPLIT-CANDIDATES.md, and HYPOTHESIS-KILL-CONDITION-REVIEW.md.
  4. Record human decisions in HYPOTHESIS-REVIEW-BOARD-DECISION.md.
  5. Approve or reject research/operating-system/hypothesis-matrix-inputs/ECR-000003-HRB-proposal.md.