research-document
ECR-000003 Hypothesis Review Board Verification
ECR-000003 Hypothesis Review Board Verification
| Check | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Every review references durable evidence | pass | each hypothesis review cites stable repository paths |
| Supporting and challenging evidence both appear | pass | every review has both sections |
| No numerical confidence introduced | pass | only qualitative enums are used |
| No hypothesis is marked proven | pass | all outcomes remain proposal-only |
| Kill conditions remain visible | pass | every review includes kill condition and status |
| Proposed values use allowed enums | pass | directions, strengths, and recommendations follow ECP vocabulary |
| Matrix changes remain proposals | pass | ECR-000003-HRB-proposal.md is proposal-only |
| Product claims remain separate | pass | no product validation claims were introduced |
| ECR-000004 is not created | pass | no new ECR directory or packet set added |
| Accepted EDRs are not overwritten | pass | this package adds review artifacts only |
| Raw response hashes remain unchanged | pass_with_warning | this package does not edit response JSON; global workspace state may still contain unrelated pre-existing changes |
| Comparator outputs remain unchanged | pass_with_warning | this package does not edit generated comparator outputs; existing outputs were treated as read-only inputs |
| Human-decision fields remain blank unless already approved | pass | decision fields are intentionally blank |
| Dashboard state matches actual artifacts | pass | board packet, summary, and decision files now exist and are referenced in state updates |