Framework Engineering Research

An open index of evidence, theory, and practice

research-document

FE-012C Agreement Tables

Research Area
General Research
Status
draft
Version
0.1
Priority
medium
Updated
2026-07-22
Source
research/experiments/FE-012C-manual-replication/reports/FE-012C-agreement-tables.md

FE-012C Agreement Tables

Per-Packet Agreement

packet_id models_present entry_agreement exit_agreement dominant_agreement shape_agreement transition_agreement recognized_count missing_primitive_count notes
FE-012C-P001 3 full full full full moderate 3 0 artifact recognized
FE-012C-P002 3 full full full full strong 3 0 artifact recognized
FE-012C-P003 3 full full full mixed strong 3 0 shape mismatch; artifact recognized
FE-012C-P004 3 full full full full strong 3 0 artifact recognized
FE-012C-P005 3 full mixed full mixed strong 3 0 exit mismatch; shape mismatch; artifact recognized
FE-012C-P006 3 full mixed mixed mixed strong 3 0 exit mismatch; dominant mismatch; shape mismatch; artifact recognized
FE-012C-P007 3 full mixed full mixed strong 3 0 exit mismatch; shape mismatch; artifact recognized
FE-012C-P008 3 full full full mixed strong 3 0 shape mismatch; artifact recognized
FE-012C-P009 3 full mixed full full strong 3 0 exit mismatch; artifact recognized
FE-012C-P010 3 full full full full strong 3 0 artifact recognized
FE-012C-P011 3 full full full full strong 3 0 artifact recognized
FE-012C-P012 3 full full mixed mixed strong 3 0 dominant mismatch; shape mismatch; artifact recognized
FE-012C-P013 3 full full full full strong 3 0 artifact recognized
FE-012C-P014 3 full full full full strong 3 0 artifact recognized
FE-012C-P015 3 full full mixed full strong 3 0 dominant mismatch; artifact recognized

Transition Frequency Table

transition count packets_seen
Bound -> Generate 15 FE-012C-P001, FE-012C-P002, FE-012C-P006, FE-012C-P008, FE-012C-P012
Reassess -> Observe 15 FE-012C-P001, FE-012C-P003, FE-012C-P004, FE-012C-P006, FE-012C-P007, FE-012C-P015
Bound -> Observe 12 FE-012C-P004, FE-012C-P007, FE-012C-P009, FE-012C-P010
Evaluate -> Decide 10 FE-012C-P001, FE-012C-P002, FE-012C-P005, FE-012C-P006
Classify -> Interpret 9 FE-012C-P003, FE-012C-P009, FE-012C-P014
Decide -> Act 9 FE-012C-P007, FE-012C-P011, FE-012C-P015
Observe -> Classify 9 FE-012C-P003, FE-012C-P009, FE-012C-P010
Act -> Reassess 6 FE-012C-P007, FE-012C-P015
Bound -> Classify 6 FE-012C-P013, FE-012C-P014
Compare -> Evaluate 6 FE-012C-P002, FE-012C-P005
Generate -> Explain 6 FE-012C-P006, FE-012C-P008
Interpret -> Decide 6 FE-012C-P003, FE-012C-P015
Verify -> Reassess 6 FE-012C-P006, FE-012C-P012
Prioritize -> Decide 4 FE-012C-P009, FE-012C-P011
Reassess -> Bound 4 FE-012C-P011, FE-012C-P012
Verify -> Decide 4 FE-012C-P001, FE-012C-P007
Act -> Reflect 3 FE-012C-P011
Act -> Verify 3 FE-012C-P012
Allocate -> Communicate 3 FE-012C-P004
Bound -> Prioritize 3 FE-012C-P011
Classify -> Compare 3 FE-012C-P005
Classify -> Evaluate 3 FE-012C-P010
Classify -> Generate 3 FE-012C-P013
Classify -> Verify 3 FE-012C-P008
Communicate -> Prioritize 3 FE-012C-P004
Coordinate -> Reassess 3 FE-012C-P004
Decide -> Communicate 3 FE-012C-P002
Decide -> Reassess 3 FE-012C-P003
Decide -> Verify 3 FE-012C-P006
Evaluate -> Communicate 3 FE-012C-P013
Evaluate -> Prioritize 3 FE-012C-P009
Explain -> Classify 3 FE-012C-P008
Explain -> Evaluate 3 FE-012C-P006
Explain -> Verify 3 FE-012C-P007
Generate -> Compare 3 FE-012C-P002
Generate -> Evaluate 3 FE-012C-P013
Generate -> Observe 3 FE-012C-P001
Generate -> Prioritize 3 FE-012C-P012
Interpret -> Evaluate 3 FE-012C-P009
Observe -> Allocate 3 FE-012C-P004
Observe -> Bound 3 FE-012C-P006
Observe -> Evaluate 3 FE-012C-P001
Observe -> Explain 3 FE-012C-P007
Observe -> Interpret 3 FE-012C-P015
Prioritize -> Communicate 3 FE-012C-P012
Prioritize -> Coordinate 3 FE-012C-P004
Reassess -> Prioritize 3 FE-012C-P011, FE-012C-P012
Reflect -> Reassess 3 FE-012C-P011
Communicate -> Act 2 FE-012C-P012
Reassess -> Allocate 2 FE-012C-P004
Communicate -> Coordinate 1 FE-012C-P012
Compare -> Decide 1 FE-012C-P005
Coordinate -> Act 1 FE-012C-P012
Evaluate -> Generate 1 FE-012C-P001
Evaluate -> Observe 1 FE-012C-P001
Evaluate -> Reassess 1 FE-012C-P001
Evaluate -> Verify 1 FE-012C-P001
Reassess -> Explain 1 FE-012C-P007
Reassess -> Generate 1 FE-012C-P001
Verify -> Generate 1 FE-012C-P001
Verify -> Observe 1 FE-012C-P001

Disagreement Table

packet_id disagreement_type gpt claude gemini notes
FE-012C-P001 Transition structure Bound -> Generate; Generate -> Observe; Observe -> Evaluate; Evaluate -> Reassess; Reassess -> Observe; Reassess -> Generate; Evaluate -> Decide Bound -> Generate; Generate -> Observe; Observe -> Evaluate; Evaluate -> Decide; Evaluate -> Observe; Evaluate -> Generate Bound -> Generate; Generate -> Observe; Observe -> Evaluate; Evaluate -> Verify; Verify -> Decide; Verify -> Observe; Verify -> Generate
FE-012C-P003 Reasoning shape Cyclic Cyclic-Branching Cyclic
FE-012C-P004 Transition structure Bound -> Observe; Observe -> Allocate; Allocate -> Communicate; Communicate -> Prioritize; Prioritize -> Coordinate; Coordinate -> Reassess; Reassess -> Allocate Bound -> Observe; Observe -> Allocate; Allocate -> Communicate; Communicate -> Prioritize; Prioritize -> Coordinate; Coordinate -> Reassess; Reassess -> Observe Bound -> Observe; Observe -> Allocate; Allocate -> Communicate; Communicate -> Prioritize; Prioritize -> Coordinate; Coordinate -> Reassess; Reassess -> Observe; Reassess -> Allocate
FE-012C-P005 Exit primitive Decide Evaluate Decide
FE-012C-P005 Reasoning shape Linear Linear Branching
FE-012C-P005 Transition structure Classify -> Compare; Compare -> Evaluate; Evaluate -> Decide Classify -> Compare; Compare -> Evaluate Classify -> Compare; Compare -> Evaluate; Compare -> Decide; Evaluate -> Decide
FE-012C-P006 Exit primitive Reassess Verify Reassess
FE-012C-P006 Dominant primitive Evaluate Generate Evaluate
FE-012C-P006 Reasoning shape Cyclic Cyclic-Branching Cyclic
FE-012C-P007 Exit primitive Reassess Act Reassess
FE-012C-P007 Reasoning shape Cyclic Cyclic-Branching Cyclic
FE-012C-P007 Transition structure Bound -> Observe; Observe -> Explain; Explain -> Verify; Verify -> Decide; Decide -> Act; Act -> Reassess; Reassess -> Observe Bound -> Observe; Observe -> Explain; Explain -> Verify; Verify -> Decide; Decide -> Act; Act -> Reassess; Reassess -> Observe Bound -> Observe; Observe -> Explain; Explain -> Verify; Verify -> Decide; Decide -> Act; Act -> Reassess; Reassess -> Observe; Reassess -> Explain
FE-012C-P008 Reasoning shape Branching Linear Linear
FE-012C-P009 Exit primitive Prioritize Prioritize Decide
FE-012C-P009 Transition structure Bound -> Observe; Observe -> Classify; Classify -> Interpret; Interpret -> Evaluate; Evaluate -> Prioritize Bound -> Observe; Observe -> Classify; Classify -> Interpret; Interpret -> Evaluate; Evaluate -> Prioritize Bound -> Observe; Observe -> Classify; Classify -> Interpret; Interpret -> Evaluate; Evaluate -> Prioritize; Prioritize -> Decide
FE-012C-P011 Transition structure Bound -> Prioritize; Prioritize -> Decide; Decide -> Act; Act -> Reflect; Reflect -> Reassess; Reassess -> Prioritize Bound -> Prioritize; Prioritize -> Decide; Decide -> Act; Act -> Reflect; Reflect -> Reassess; Reassess -> Bound Bound -> Prioritize; Prioritize -> Decide; Decide -> Act; Act -> Reflect; Reflect -> Reassess; Reassess -> Bound
FE-012C-P012 Dominant primitive Prioritize Communicate Coordinate
FE-012C-P012 Reasoning shape Cyclic Cyclic-Branching Cyclic
FE-012C-P012 Transition structure Bound -> Generate; Generate -> Prioritize; Prioritize -> Communicate; Communicate -> Act; Act -> Verify; Verify -> Reassess; Reassess -> Prioritize Bound -> Generate; Generate -> Prioritize; Prioritize -> Communicate; Communicate -> Act; Act -> Verify; Verify -> Reassess; Reassess -> Bound Bound -> Generate; Generate -> Prioritize; Prioritize -> Communicate; Communicate -> Coordinate; Coordinate -> Act; Act -> Verify; Verify -> Reassess; Reassess -> Bound; Reassess -> Prioritize
FE-012C-P015 Dominant primitive Act Observe Decide