Capability Role Review Results

FE-012C-P001 GPT

Case Metadata

• Packet ID: FE-012C-P001
• Provider: GPT
• Reviewer:
• Date:
• Prior response path: research/experiments/FE-012C-manual-replication/responses/gpt/FE-012C-P001-gpt.json
• Repeat response path: research/experiments/FE-012C-repeatability-run-001/responses/gpt/01.json

Primitive Sequence (Prior)

Bound -> Generate -> Observe -> Evaluate -> Reassess -> Decide

Primitive Sequence (Repeat)

Bound -> Generate -> Observe -> Evaluate -> Compare -> Verify -> Reassess -> Generate -> Observe -> Evaluate -> Decide

Capability Role Sequence (Prior)

Capability Role Sequence (Repeat)

Backbone Review

• Did the entry role change?
• Did the exit role change?
• Did the dominant role change?
• Did the major reasoning path change?
• Did loop control materially change?
• Did branch structure materially change?

Classification

Reasoning

Comparator Implication

Notes

FE-012C-P003 Claude

Case Metadata

• Packet ID: FE-012C-P003
• Provider: Claude
• Reviewer:
• Date:
• Prior response path: research/experiments/FE-012C-manual-replication/responses/claude/FE-012C-P003-claude.json
• Repeat response path: research/experiments/FE-012C-repeatability-run-001/responses/claude/03.json

Primitive Sequence (Prior)

Observe -> Classify -> Interpret -> Decide -> Reassess

Primitive Sequence (Repeat)

Observe -> Classify -> Interpret -> Decide -> Act -> Reassess

Capability Role Sequence (Prior)

Capability Role Sequence (Repeat)

Backbone Review

• Did the entry role change?
• Did the exit role change?
• Did the dominant role change?
• Did the major reasoning path change?
• Did loop control materially change?
• Did branch structure materially change?

Classification

Reasoning

Comparator Implication

Notes

FE-012C-P007 Gemini

Case Metadata

• Packet ID: FE-012C-P007
• Provider: Gemini
• Reviewer:
• Date:
• Prior response path: research/experiments/FE-012C-manual-replication/responses/gemini/FE-012C-P007-gemini.json
• Repeat response path: research/experiments/FE-012C-repeatability-run-001/responses/gemini/07.json

Primitive Sequence (Prior)

Bound -> Observe -> Explain -> Verify -> Decide -> Act -> Reassess

Primitive Sequence (Repeat)

Bound -> Observe -> Explain -> Verify -> Decide -> Act -> Reassess

Capability Role Sequence (Prior)

Capability Role Sequence (Repeat)

Backbone Review

• Did the entry role change?
• Did the exit role change?
• Did the dominant role change?
• Did the major reasoning path change?
• Did loop control materially change?
• Did branch structure materially change?

Classification

Reasoning

Comparator Implication

Notes

FE-012C-P011 Claude

Case Metadata

• Packet ID: FE-012C-P011
• Provider: Claude
• Reviewer:
• Date:
• Prior response path: research/experiments/FE-012C-manual-replication/responses/claude/FE-012C-P011-claude.json
• Repeat response path: research/experiments/FE-012C-repeatability-run-001/responses/claude/11.json

Primitive Sequence (Prior)

Bound -> Prioritize -> Decide -> Act -> Reflect -> Reassess

Primitive Sequence (Repeat)

Bound -> Prioritize -> Decide -> Act -> Reflect -> Reassess

Capability Role Sequence (Prior)

Capability Role Sequence (Repeat)

Backbone Review

• Did the entry role change?
• Did the exit role change?
• Did the dominant role change?
• Did the major reasoning path change?
• Did loop control materially change?
• Did branch structure materially change?

Classification

Reasoning

Comparator Implication

Notes

FE-012C-P014 GPT

Case Metadata

• Packet ID: FE-012C-P014
• Provider: GPT
• Reviewer:
• Date:
• Prior response path: research/experiments/FE-012C-manual-replication/responses/gpt/FE-012C-P014-gpt.json
• Repeat response path: research/experiments/FE-012C-repeatability-run-001/responses/gpt/14.json

Primitive Sequence (Prior)

Bound -> Classify -> Interpret

Primitive Sequence (Repeat)

Bound -> Observe -> Classify -> Compare -> Interpret -> Evaluate -> Reflect -> Communicate

Capability Role Sequence (Prior)

Capability Role Sequence (Repeat)

Backbone Review

• Did the entry role change?
• Did the exit role change?
• Did the dominant role change?
• Did the major reasoning path change?
• Did loop control materially change?
• Did branch structure materially change?

Classification

Reasoning

Comparator Implication

Notes