research-document

FE-012C Backbone Agreement

FE-012C Backbone Agreement

Backbone comparison covers:

  • entry_primitive
  • exit_primitive
  • dominant_primitive
  • reasoning_shape
  • major primitive path after removing elaboration primitives
Packet ID Provider Entry Exit Dominant Shape Major Path Semantic Category
FE-012C-P001 gpt yes yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P002 gpt no yes no yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P003 gpt yes yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P004 gpt no yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P005 gpt yes no yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P006 gpt yes yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P007 gpt yes no no yes yes structural_drift
FE-012C-P008 gpt no yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P009 gpt yes no yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P010 gpt yes yes yes yes yes stable
FE-012C-P011 gpt yes yes no yes yes structural_drift
FE-012C-P012 gpt no yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P013 gpt no yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P014 gpt yes no yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P015 gpt yes yes no yes yes structural_drift
FE-012C-P001 claude yes yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P002 claude yes yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P003 claude yes yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P004 claude yes yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P005 claude no yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P006 claude yes yes no yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P007 claude no no yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P008 claude no yes no yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P009 claude yes no yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P010 claude yes yes yes yes yes stable
FE-012C-P011 claude yes yes yes yes yes unclear
FE-012C-P012 claude yes yes no yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P013 claude yes yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P014 claude yes no yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P015 claude yes yes no yes yes structural_drift
FE-012C-P001 gemini yes yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P002 gemini yes no yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P003 gemini yes yes no yes yes structural_drift
FE-012C-P004 gemini yes yes yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P005 gemini yes no yes yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P006 gemini yes yes yes yes yes structural_drift
FE-012C-P007 gemini yes yes yes yes yes stable
FE-012C-P008 gemini yes yes no yes yes structural_drift
FE-012C-P009 gemini yes yes no yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P010 gemini yes yes yes yes yes stable
FE-012C-P011 gemini yes yes yes yes yes structural_drift
FE-012C-P012 gemini yes yes no yes no structural_drift
FE-012C-P013 gemini yes yes yes yes yes stable
FE-012C-P014 gemini yes yes yes yes yes stable
FE-012C-P015 gemini yes no no yes yes structural_drift

Summary

  • Stable: 6
  • Elaboration drift: 0
  • Structural drift: 38
  • Unclear: 1