Independent Evaluation — EX-LEGACY-FE-011A vlegacy-import-1.0

Role

Historical replication evaluator; consult the original protocol before any new run.

Question and claim

Question: What results were recorded by FE-011A LLM Blind Pilot?

Primary hypothesis: FE-011A

Claim under test: Historical claim retained without reinterpretation during migration.

Permitted inputs

• research/experiments/FE-011A-llm-blind-pilot/README.md (EX-LEGACY-FE-011A-README.md)
• research/experiments/FE-011A-llm-blind-pilot/protocol.md (EX-LEGACY-FE-011A-protocol.md)
• research/experiments/FE-011A-llm-blind-pilot/analysis-plan.md (EX-LEGACY-FE-011A-analysis-plan.md)

Use only the files listed above. Do not inspect runs/, normalized/, comparisons/, adjudications/, or synthesis/. Another evaluator's result is not a permitted input.

Procedure

1. Read the original protocol and declared inputs.
2. Run an independent replication without reading migrated results.
3. Return a schema-conforming result for a new run.

Required adversarial test

Attempt to falsify the primary hypothesis. At minimum, test:

• The original experiment's declared kill or failure conditions are met.

Separate observed evidence from inference and recommendation. Record assumptions, uncertainty, counterexamples, competing explanations, blockers, and completion status. Cite repository paths and stable artifact IDs for every material evidence claim.

Do not modify canonical inputs or any other evaluator's records. Return a machine-readable result conforming to research/framework-engineering/experiments/schemas/normalized-result.schema.json, followed by a concise human-readable explanation. The runner or human operator—not the evaluator—persists the response into its collision-resistant run directory.