research-document

ECR-000003 Board Proposal For Hypothesis Evidence Matrix

Research Area: General Research
Status: draft
Version: 0.1
Priority: medium
Updated: 2026-07-22
Source: research/operating-system/hypothesis-matrix-inputs/ECR-000003-board-proposal.md

ECR-000003 Board Proposal For Hypothesis Evidence Matrix

Status: proposal_only

Do not update the durable hypothesis evidence matrix automatically from this file.

Hypothesis	Prior Value	Proposed Value	Supporting Evidence	Challenging Evidence	Kill-Condition Status	Reviewer	Decision Date
H002	active / low-moderate	mixed / weak	`EXP-002` representation compliance; `EXP-003` mostly stable backbone	primitive and constraint disagreement across representation changes	tested_not_met	pending human review	pending
H003	active / moderate	slightly_supported / weak	`EXP-003` mostly stable backbone across providers	mixed backbone in `EXP-001` and `EXP-002`; provider-specific recognition patterns	partially_met	pending human review	pending
H013	active / moderate	mixed / moderate	leakage findings and recognition persistence patterns	recognition varied while backbone sometimes remained stable	tested_not_met	pending human review	pending
H015	active / moderate	slightly_supported / moderate	certified datasets, frozen comparator, explainability outputs	tolerant parsing events and no human baseline	tested_not_met	pending human review	pending
H016	active / low	waiting / insufficient	topology perturbation keeps the question active	no clean graph-only control in accepted evidence	not_tested	pending human review	pending
H017	active / low	mixed / weak	compression/elaboration patterns visible in explainability	mixed backbone and disagreement remain	partially_met	pending human review	pending
H018	proposed / very low	slightly_supported / weak	`EXP-003` mostly stable backbone across domains	primitive, transition, and constraint disagreement; leakage findings	tested_not_met	pending human review	pending

Sources:

research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/review-board/HYPOTHESIS-REVIEW-BOARD.md
research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/ECR-000003-FINDINGS.md