ECR-000003 Hypothesis Review Board Proposal

Status: proposal_only

Do not update the durable hypothesis matrix automatically from this file.

H002 Representation Independence

• Current matrix state: active / low-moderate
• Proposed state: slightly_supported / weak
• Evidence references:
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/experiments/EXP-002-cross-representation-stability/comparison/generated-v3.1/exp-002-comparison-summary.md
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/experiments/EXP-003-isomorphic-procedures/comparison/generated-v3.1/comparison-summary.md
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/comparison/ECR-000003-explainability-summary.md
• Rationale: limited backbone-level robustness across representations, but not broad multi-layer independence
• Kill-condition status: tested_not_met
• Reviewer approval:

H003 Multi-Model Convergence

• Current matrix state: active / moderate
• Proposed state: slightly_supported / weak
• Evidence references:
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/experiments/EXP-001-topology-perturbation/comparison/generated-v3.1/exp-001-comparison-summary.md
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/experiments/EXP-002-cross-representation-stability/comparison/generated-v3.1/exp-002-comparison-summary.md
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/experiments/EXP-003-isomorphic-procedures/comparison/generated-v3.1/comparison-summary.md
• Rationale: bounded cross-provider convergence exists, especially at backbone layers
• Kill-condition status: partially_met
• Reviewer approval:

H013 Recognition Bias

• Current matrix state: active / moderate
• Proposed state: mixed / moderate
• Evidence references:
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/comparison/ECR-000003-explainability-summary.md
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/experiments/EXP-003-isomorphic-procedures/comparison/generated-v3.1/comparison-summary.md
• Rationale: recognition pressure is active, but its structural importance is inconsistent
• Kill-condition status: tested_not_met
• Reviewer approval:

H015 Measurement Instrument Reliability

• Current matrix state: active / moderate
• Proposed state: supported / moderate
• Evidence references:
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/response-filename-verification-report.md
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/pipeline/generated/ecr-000003-final-readiness-report.md
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/comparison/comparator-3.2-explainability-implementation-report.md
• Rationale: the instrument operated successfully for bounded research use despite visible caveats
• Kill-condition status: tested_not_met
• Reviewer approval:

H016 Structural Recognition

• Current matrix state: active / low
• Proposed state: waiting / insufficient
• Evidence references:
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/experiments/EXP-001-topology-perturbation/comparison/generated-v3.1/exp-001-comparison-summary.md
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/comparison/ECR-000003-explainability-summary.md
• Rationale: the question remains active, but accepted evidence is not decisive
• Kill-condition status: not_tested
• Reviewer approval:

H017 Procedural Compression

• Current matrix state: active / low
• Proposed state: slightly_supported / weak
• Evidence references:
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/experiments/EXP-002-cross-representation-stability/comparison/generated-v3.1/exp-002-comparison-summary.md
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/comparison/ECR-000003-explainability-summary.md
• Rationale: compression-like behavior is visible, but not yet broad or strong
• Kill-condition status: partially_met
• Reviewer approval:

H018 Procedural Isomorphism

• Current matrix state: proposed / very low
• Proposed state: slightly_supported / weak
• Evidence references:
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/experiments/EXP-003-isomorphic-procedures/comparison/generated-v3.1/comparison-summary.md
  • research/evidence-runs/ECR-000003-representation-sensitivity/experiments/EXP-003-isomorphic-procedures/comparison/generated-v3.2-explainability/isomorphic-procedure-explainability.md
• Rationale: cross-domain backbone similarity is the strongest ECR-000003 theoretical signal, but remains provisional
• Kill-condition status: tested_not_met
• Reviewer approval: