ECR Review Template

Accepted Experiment Reviews

• EXP001:
• EXP002:
• EXP003:

Observations That Survived Review

Observations Rejected During Review

Hypotheses With New Evidence

Hypotheses With Reduced Support

Inconclusive Observations

Recommended Next Experiment

Explainability Questions

• Is the disagreement lexical or structural?
• Does the difference alter the backbone?
• Is one response compressed or expanded?
• Did a model add unsupported structure?
• Did recognition affect extraction?
• Did domain vocabulary affect the result?
• Is the difference scientifically relevant?
• Does it expose a comparator limitation?
• Should it affect hypothesis review?
• Is additional evidence required?

Claims Now Supportable

Claims Remaining Unsupported

Review Outcome

• Accepted
• Accepted with Notes
• Needs Revision
• Deferred